Has Anyone Actually Seen ‘Watchmen’?


Thoughts from Kevin Boyd of the University of Chicago Divinity School on the most under-criticised film of the year:

” Watchmen directly asks what no other superhero movie has ever had the courage or audacity to posit: Is society actually worth saving? In this sense Watchmen is not just about the flawed psychologies of its costumed adventurers; it is perhaps the first superhero movie to take the concept of universal sin seriously. The traditional superhero film employs a formulaic template: Evil threatens the established social order until good intervenes. The roles of good and evil are clearly and easily defined. This simple narrative structure is built on two premises that, until recently, have gone unchallenged in the genre. The first is the unambiguous coupling of the hero with the moral good and the villain with moral evil … The second premise, though, has until now remained virtually unassailable, and it is this element that makes Watchmen so interesting and so difficult to digest. The second premise is that society is worth saving, that the social order under threat is worthy of salvation. In most previous superhero films the desire to uphold the social order is simply taken as a given – society is good and it must be saved from the threat of evil. But in Watchmen the immediate crisis of mutually assured nuclear destruction is not caused by one discreet individual; there is no named villain. Instead, the threat is posed by the morally bankrupt social order itself. Evil is not external to the social order; it is characteristic of it. As Watchmen member Rorschach states, “The world will look up and shout ‘Save us!’… And I’ll whisper ‘No.’” … In a particularly poignant moment in the film, the hero Night Owl looks out on a murderous rampage by the sadistic hero (and his co-Watchman) The Comedian and asks, “What happened to the American Dream?” The Comedian responds, “It came true. You’re looking at it.”

In our current world of political discourse and economic crises, perhaps The Comedian’s response hits a little too close to home. Situated between a “war on terror” and world-wide economic collapse we inhabit a time where sin feels omnipresent. What we lack is a robust way to speak about it. We’ve lost the Niebuhrian sense of ourselves as our own most vexing problem. And yet just as the neo-orthodox theologians resurrected the notion of human sin in response to world war, so too must we find new ways to name and speak of our experiences; in a fashion, films like this are the first steps in such a process because they show a world saturated in sin – a world that is sometimes uncomfortably too like our own. The film offers no easy answers, though. After all, the dominant narrative voice that structures most of the action is that of Rorschach, in every sense an absolutist and a fascist. We might think of Watchmen as the first segment of a traditional jeremiad, a literary text lamenting the moral failure of society and warning of its ultimate collapse without immediate and genuine repentance – but given the extreme pessimism of Watchmen’s anthropology one must wonder whether society, even when violently compelled, is capable of sustaining the momentum towards such repentance. The unsettled feeling many experience leaving the theater may come from the fact that this film, perhaps for the first time in the superhero genre, hints that it might already be too late to stop the Doomsday Clock.”


One response to “Has Anyone Actually Seen ‘Watchmen’?

  1. Yeah I saw Watchmen, and I am glad I did. I’d never claim to know what something is supposed to be about, so I wouldn’t want to try and proclaim what it is trying to say, or how what the movie says is different than what the graphic novel said.

    This is the movie where I finally realized that it wasn’t something wrong with the production of the last few superhero movies. I am just flat out sick and disgusted with the superhero. The fantasy that it is cool to have enough power to casually walk in slow motion towards a goal, throwing bodies off of you like raindrops. Giant blue man in the rice paddies throwing bolts of energy full of power and empty of emotion, or the spandex clad lovers dancing with each other in a prison hallyway only barely aware that their dance is killing people.

    I am suddenly nostalgic for the 60s tv batman, where we had the wisdom to check this worship of power by mocking it at every turn.

    Beyond the superhero thing, the movie bugged me because it wants us to believe that it is fear of power, fear of consequences, which is what is needed to cause us to rise above the animal. This is the “fear of the lord is the beginning of wisdom” old testament god that men need to keep them in check.

    And we have the powerful assuming the role that current mythology insists that all powers must, to cause evil, with intent and purpose, in order to preserve what little good may exist.

    I am glad I saw the movie, because it made me think about these things. I would even say that this makes it a good movie.